Edinburgh Branch Seminar

Hybrid PESGB Seminar Series ‘Labouring over Words: Exploring the intrinsic educational significance and pedagogical practice of reading and writing’

Doctoral Reading as ‘Riffing’ and the Rhythms of Higher Learning
Dr Fadia Dakka (Birmingham City University)

Organised by Dr Aline Nardo (University of Edinburgh) and Dr Shari Sabeti (University of Edinburgh); co-sponsored by the Arts and Humanities in Education Research Group (AHERG) at the University of Edinburgh

This paper takes reading, rather than writing, as the central marker of engagement with higher learning, and asks what follows for doctoral education in the twenty-first century.

Work across educational, literary and cognitive fields reports a decline in deep reading, with serious implications for critical analysis and creativity, and points to a transformation of the reading brain in an environment increasingly dominated by Large Language Models. Alongside a higher education landscape shaped by intense marketisation and quantification, this produces doctoral education oriented towards writing-as-output rather than to writing as inquiry or a ‘field of play’ (Richardson 1997). Reading is correspondingly instrumentalised, managed through skim and speed-reading techniques on the unspoken assumption that it belongs to the preparatory stages of a thesis. Against this backdrop, I reframe doctoral reading as a research orientation and a philosophical practice with ethical and pedagogical implications, drawing on a British Academy/Leverhulme-funded international project (2024–25) that explored how Norwegian and English doctoral students experience reading in their daily lives. Theoretically, the paper works with an ontology of reading as ‘a dynamic of attraction and response’ (Macé & Jones,2013), foregrounding Iser’s attention to the reader’s wandering viewpoint, the text’s indeterminacies, and the open-endedness of interpretation. It is argued that the paradox and promise of higher learning lie in this challenging yet promising encounter between the student’s lifeworld and the world of an unknown text: a simultaneous experience of ‘bafflement and effort’ (Collini ,2011).

The paper then turns to pedagogy and rhythm. It discusses the ‘Circle of Voices’, a pedagogical intervention in which a shared text is read aloud and dwelt on collectively, considering what it makes possible: the recovery of orality, slowness as an onto-epistemological stance, and interpretation as a shared rather than a solitary endeavour. It then scrutinises the rhythms of doctoral reading to reveal a tension between the institution’s linear rhythms and rhuthmós (form in motion), which sustains ‘a rhythm of one’s own’ (Barthes, 1977), amidst institutional, professional and personal constraints.

Finally, the paper gestures towards mobilising students’ own creative interpretations and the author’s theorisation of rhythm (Dakka 2021, 2024), introducing doctoral reading as ‘riffing’: a first step towards a rhythm-inspired praxis with transformative potential for contemporary doctoral and higher education.

Fadia Dakka is an Associate Professor of Philosophy and Theory of Higher Education at Birmingham City University, where she directs CSPACE and serves as Academic Lead for Research in the Department of Education. Her latest work develops a rhythmanalytic philosophy of higher education, drawing on Lefebvre, Barthes and the pre-Socratic concept of rhuthmós to examine the complex temporalities of higher learning and contemporary reading practices. She recently led a British Academy/Leverhulme-funded project on doctoral reading in England and Norway, and serves on the editorial boards of several journals, including Critical Studies in Education, Time & Society, Ethics & Education and Philosophy and Theory in Higher Education.

Join Microsoft Teams meeting:
https://teams.microsoft.com/meet/343982631380379?p=TqmLvDUYzIouHV5FqW
Meeting ID: 343 982 631 380 379
Passcode: ZA2J62bz