Book Review: A Philosophical Inquiry into Subject English and Creative Writing

By Áine Mahon

A Philosophical Inquiry into Subject English and Creative Writing by Oli Belas

A Philosophical Inquiry into Subject English and Creative Writing book cover

Book cover for Belas (2023). Taken from the Routledge catalogue.

Routledge, 2023.

ISBN: 9780367487362, Hbk.

ISBN: 9781032374581, Pbk.

ISBN: 9781003042617, eBook. 

RRP: £125.00 / £38.99 / £35.09, 156pp.

Oli Belas’s new book offers an intelligent and lively account of school-level English in the UK, and the need to rethink its core approaches and philosophies. A Philosophical Inquiry is animated by its central argument to recentre the practice of writing in all educational contexts, but especially for students at second level. As Belas thoughtfully outlines, writing is not just reportage but is a key educational tool; it is a mode of thinking through which the young person can find empowerment, expression, and joy. Writes Belas with characteristic understatement: ‘Writing is overlooked in schooled English, and it would be a good idea if this were not the case” (p. 12). He therefore advocates for a “writerly shift”, “a call for students to be able to dwell and play in language” (p. 24).

The contribution of this book is profound. Not only is it written by an experienced second-level teacher who is impressively versed in the curricular and social issues at play, but it is continuously underpinned by a scholarly expertise ranging from empirical educational research to critical theory to philosophy of education. Belas’s range and depth here is striking, as is his ability to stay very much in control of an understandably unwieldy set of issues.

Belas’s book has much to say to teachers of English at primary and second level, but it is in conversation also with practices of reading and writing as they are imagined in the university context. He is particularly good on the distinction between “writing up” and “writing through”, and the importance to academic researchers of imagining their work in terms of the latter rather than the former. To this extent, his final chapter entitled “Thinking as a Kind of Writing, Writing as a Kind of Philosophy; or, on Lightbulb Moments”, is a particular gift to any of us who have struggled with our writing as students and researchers in academia, and who perhaps still wonder whether we can recover the joy from our earlier writing and reading biographies.

Belas writes with notable flair, and his discussions move lightly from Analytic Philosophy to Phenomenology to Literary Criticism. Indeed, the author’s trust in and commitment to his own voice is a notable feature and strength of this book. A Philosophical Inquiry is itself an act of creative writing. It proceeds in a spirit of experiment and self-exploration. Performing its own core theme, the book deliberately wrestles with its own attempts to bring thought to language via writing. It therefore achieves an intimacy and insight not always available in academic writing, and gently encourages its reader to re-think their own writerly practice.

In sum: this is a gem of a book. It is comprehensive, imaginative, scholarly, incisive, and fun.  In A Philosophical Inquiry, Belas’s advocacy for writing as practice – his call that in the teaching of English we re-centre the person as well as the text and thus recalibrate what the study of this subject is actually for – is given impressive clarity and urgency through his own achievement of this wonderfully writerly and provocative piece of work. Belas writes that there is “something akin to magic in our most profound encounters with literature” (p. 13). This reviewer is certainly still under the spell of this surprising and gorgeous book.

About the Author

Áine Mahon

Áine Mahon

Dr Áine Mahon is Associate Professor in Philosophy of Education in the School of Education at University College Dublin. Her first monograph, The Ironist and the Romantic: Reading Richard Rorty and Stanley Cavell, was published by Bloomsbury in 2014. With Andrew Taylor of the University of Edinburgh, she has edited Stanley Cavell, Literature and Film: The Idea of America (Routledge, 2013); and with Clara Fischer of Queen’s University Belfast, she has edited Philosophical Perspectives on Contemporary Ireland (Routledge, 2019). Her most recent book, The Promise of the University: Reclaiming Humanity, Humility, and Hope was published by Springer in 2021.


By this Author

    Comments

    1. The Pearl Pdf Audio

      When Kino tries to sell his pearl in the town of La Paz, he is met with a conspiracy of pearl buyers working for a single boss to cheat him. This realization that the game is rigged against him is a pivotal moment of awakening. It transforms Kino from a passive victim into a man willing to kill to protect his rights. If you are analyzing the economic themes of the novel, having the pearl pdf handy makes it easier to cite the dialogue between Kino and the dealers. It is a powerful illustration of the exploitation of labor and the difficulty of breaking out of established social hierarchies.

      Reply
    2. The Pearl John Steinbeck Chapter 1 Pdf

      The trackers who hunt Kino and his family in the final chapters are terrifying because of their faceless efficiency. They represent the inevitable consequence of Kino’s disruption of the social order. The suspense built during the chase scene is palpable. Readers often search for the pearl pdf to experience this thriller-like section of the book. The interaction between the hunter and the hunted in the desolate mountains highlights Kino’s regression to a primal state. He must become as ruthless as the wild animals to protect his family, shedding his humanity in the process.

      Reply
    3. What Is A Crux In Shield Of Sparrows

      Modern readers appreciate the flexibility of ebooks, and Shield of Sparrows by Devney Perry is a title that deserves a spot on your device. The demand for the shield of sparrows epub highlights just how popular this author has become. By choosing the digital route, you save shelf space while still enjoying a premium reading experience. Perry’s characters come to life on the page, pulling you into their world of passion and drama. Whether you use an app or a dedicated device, this book is formatted to look great. treat yourself to this digital gem and enjoy the story.

      Reply
    4. Haunting Adeline Book 2 Free Pdf

      Are you afraid of the dark? You should be. Zade Meadows lives there. If you are looking for the Haunting Adeline PDF, you are brave enough to enter. The book is a scary, sexy, and suspenseful read. It is a story that will keep you guessing. It is a novel that is unforgettable.

      Reply
    5. Empire Of Storms Pdf Online Free​

      The concept of sacrifice is explored in all its painful reality. Characters have to give up parts of themselves to win. Reading the Empire of Storms PDF can be an emotional endurance test. The author does not coddle her characters or her readers. It is a gritty, realistic take on the cost of heroism.

      Reply
    6. Celeste Ng Everything I Never Told You Epub​

      Jack, the neighbor boy, plays a crucial role in the mystery. He is the one person who sees Lydia for who she really is. His relationship with the Lee siblings is complicated and surprising. If you are looking for the Everything I Never Told You PDF, you will be intrigued by this subplot. It adds another layer of depth to the story, exploring themes of friendship, sexuality, and misunderstanding. It is a nuanced portrayal of teenage relationships in a time of social change.

      Reply
    7. Mockingjay Pdf Online Free

      The intricate design of the Capitol’s defense system turns the city into the 76th Hunger Games. Katniss and her squad must navigate a labyrinth of death traps to reach Snow. To join them on this mission, secure a Mockingjay PDF for your e-reader or tablet. The digital text flows validly, allowing for an immersive reading experience that physical books can’t always match in portability. The suspense is relentless, keeping you on the edge of your seat. See how the Girl on Fire burns down the old world.

      Reply
    8. The Road By Mccarthy Pdf

      What remains when the world ends? In The Road, only ash and love remain. Cormac McCarthy’s novel is a brutal look at the end of days, but it is also a tender portrayal of parenthood. The man’s devotion to the boy is absolute. This book won the Pulitzer Prize and captured the imagination of the world. For ease of access, many readers look for a digital copy or pdf. It is a story that resonates with anyone who has ever feared for the future of their loved ones.

      Reply
    9. Queen Of Shadows Dianne Sylvan Epub

      The climax of this novel is one of the most explosive in the series, resolving several long-standing plot threads while opening up terrifying new ones. The confrontation with the King of Adarlan reveals secrets that change everything we thought we knew about the history of Erilea. If you are searching for a Queen of Shadows pdf, be prepared for a sleepless night as you race to the finish. The revelation regarding the source of the King’s power and the true nature of the enemy is a game-changer. It perfectly sets the scene for the global conflict to come.

      Reply
    10. Pride And Prejudice Pdf Free

      The chemistry between the leads is undeniable, even on the page. The sparks fly from their first meeting. To feel the heat, you need to read the words. A digital format captures this energy. If you are looking for a Pride and Prejudice PDF, you are looking for passion. Our platform champions the romance of the novel. Experience the love story that set the bar for all others.

      Reply
    11. Better Than The Movies Mobi

      Prepare for a serious book hangover after you finish this gem. The emotional investment you will have in Wes and Liz is significant. Many readers start by looking for a Better Than the Movies PDF to see what the hype is about and end up buying a physical copy too. It is a story that captures the intensity of teenage feelings without ever being condescending or cliché.

      Reply
    12. East Of Eden Chapter 12 Pdf

      The concept of the “tragedy of the commons” isn’t explicitly stated, but the exploitation of the land is a background theme. The shift from family farming to business is depicted with nostalgia and resignation. Economics students can find interesting parallels here. An East of Eden PDF allows for keyword searches related to business and farming. Our content discusses the economic shifts in the Salinas Valley, adding a layer of sociological analysis to the reading. We broaden the scope of the novel beyond just the family drama.

      Reply
    13. Pride And Prejudice Abridged Pdf

      Lady Catherine de Bourgh is one of the most memorable antagonists in literature. Her confrontation with Elizabeth is a masterclass in dialogue. To witness this battle, you need the text. A Pride and Prejudice PDF allows you to read this scene again and again. Our platform is dedicated to the memorable moments of the book. We provide access to the scenes that everyone talks about. Stand up to bullies with Elizabeth Bennet.

      Reply
    14. Twisted Love Free Book Pdf

      Twisted Love is a modern classic that has defined a sub-genre of romance. It combines the best elements of New Adult, dark romance, and suspense. If you haven’t read it yet, the Twisted Love PDF is waiting for you. The story of Alex and Ava is one for the ages. It is a book that you will want to recommend to all your friends.

      Reply
    15. The Summer I Turned Pretty 3 Epub

      The summer house is full of ghosts of the past and promises of the future. Jenny Han balances these themes expertly. Searching for “The Summer I Turned Pretty PDF” reveals a story of deep emotional resonance. Belly is caught between two brothers and two versions of herself. The narrative is driven by her internal monologue and her interactions with the boys. It is a book that feels like a long, hot summer day.

      Reply
    16. Twisted Love Pdf Online

      Ava Chen is a heroine who is easy to love; she is kind, creative, and brave. Her influence on Alex is gradual but profound. Those who read the Twisted Love PDF often cite Ava’s character arc as a highlight. She learns to stand up for herself, even against the man she loves. The book creates a balanced relationship where both partners grow and change. It is a modern romance that respects the agency of its female lead.

      Reply
    17. Download Pdf The Summer I Turned Pretty

      If you are a fan of slow-burn romance, this book is for you. Jenny Han takes her time building the relationships. The PDF of The Summer I Turned Pretty is a gateway to a world of angst and affection. Belly’s internal conflict is portrayed with sensitivity. She loves them both, but in different ways. The story explores the confusion of the teenage heart. It is a tender and memorable read.

      Reply
    18. The Awakening Full Pdf

      Chopin’s writing is subtle; she never preaches. She presents the facts and lets the reader judge. To experience this objective storytelling, get the awakening pdf. It is a refreshing change from moralizing literature. The digital text allows you to form your own ethical conclusions.

      Reply
    19. Animal Farm Test Review Pdf

      Protect your mind against propaganda by studying how it works. Animal Farm is the best textbook for this. Squealer is the professor. Attend the class by reading the Animal Farm PDF. It is an education in skepticism that pays dividends forever.

      Reply
    20. The Awakening And Selected Short Stories By Kate Chopin Pdf

      The novel is a reminder that life is short and we must live it on our own terms. To get this wake-up call, read the awakening pdf. It is a book that demands action. The digital format puts the power in your hands.

      Reply
    21. Animal Farm Full Text Pdf

      The ultimate lesson is that liberty requires eternal vigilance. The animals fell asleep, and their freedom was stolen. Stay awake. Read the Animal Farm PDF. Keep your eyes open.

      Reply
    22. Onyx Storm Book Epub Free

      It is rare for a third book in a series to maintain the momentum of the first two, but this novel manages to exceed all expectations. The world-building expands significantly, introducing new locations and terrifying enemies. If you are trying to find the Onyx Storm epub, you are likely preparing for a sleepless night of binge-reading. The dynamic between the dragons and their riders is explored with even more depth, adding layers to the magical system. This is not just a romance; it is a war story with high stakes and devastating losses. The electronic version ensures you can highlight your favorite quotes and moments instantly.

      Reply
    23. D&D 5E Xanathar's Guide To Everything 5E Pdf

      Whether you are a veteran or a newbie, Xanathar’s Guide to Everything has something for you. It expands the horizon of what is possible in 5th Edition. If you are looking for a PDF introduction to the book’s contents, our overview articles are perfect. We summarize the key additions without the fluff. Get straight to the good stuff and enhance your tabletop experience with the ultimate guide to everything.

      Reply
    24. King Of Wrath Español Pdf Gratis

      Imagine being engaged to a man who actively dislikes you, only to find out he is the only one who truly sees you. That is the reality for Vivian Lau. Dante Russo is a complex anti-hero who will frustrate and fascinate you in equal measure. Readers often look for the King of Wrath PDF to experience the emotional highs and lows of this turbulent relationship. The narrative explores themes of family expectations and self-discovery, wrapped in a seductive package of billionaire romance. It is a book that stays with you long after the final chapter.

      Reply
    25. Hunger Games Sunrise On The Reaping Pdf Free

      The bread that Peeta tossed to a starving Katniss years ago is a recurring motif. It symbolizes hope, debt, and survival. The “Boy with the Bread” is a central figure in Katniss’s psyche. To understand the significance of this flashback, you must read the text. The movies touch on it, but the book explains it fully. A The Hunger Games pdf is a great resource for readers who want to trace the symbolism of bread throughout the novel.

      Reply
    26. The Hunger Games Study Guide Pdf

      Interviews with the tributes are mandatory viewing in Panem. They are a mix of beauty pageant and death row confessionals. The absurdity is highlighted in the text. Katniss hates every second of it. Her internal monologue during the interviews is hilarious and heartbreaking. To hear her true thoughts, read the novel. A The Hunger Games pdf lets you see behind the scenes of the glamour and understand the true horror of the situation.

      Reply